It’s called a correction and it hasn’t happened in a while, but it is happening now to the Nasdaq and the Russell 2k. My panel of financial advisors and experts discuss what a correction is, what stocks are causing it, the impact it has on other stocks and whether it will spread to the other indices. We also discuss NVidia and the anticipated IPO of Anthropic.
[00:00:00] Welcome to the latest edition of The Bull, The Bear and You as we navigate what is happening in the economy and we take a look at investing. I'm Stacy Smith and I urge you to subscribe or say that you like this podcast on whatever platform you happen to use. It's called a correction and it has not happened in a while, but it's happening now to the NASDAQ and the Russell 2000. My panel of financial advisors and experts will discuss what a correction is, what stocks are causing it, the impact it has on other stocks and whether it can spread to other indices.
[00:00:30] We'll also discuss NVIDIA and the anticipated IPO of Anthropic. It's coming up in this edition of The Bull, The Bear and You. And with me to talk about the economy and investing is my panel of financial advisors and experts and they are Kerry Coghill, the founder of Coghill Investment Strategies.
[00:00:57] Next we find Frank Rossetti. Frank has his own alternative investment company, HF Management. Kim Forrest is the founder and chief investment officer for Boca Capital Partners. And we find Michael Godwin of Fregasso Financial Advisors. Jim Senegal is the chief investment officer for Fregasso. I guess you've changed your name to Fregasso Wealth Advisors. So I'll have to get that in my mind all the time. Thanks again for joining me for The Bull, The Bear and You. You know, for some time Frank Brissetti has been saying the markets are overdue for a correction.
[00:01:26] Just as a reminder, a stock or an indice enters correction territory when it drops 10% from its recent high. Well, for the NASDAQ, that time is here. As of the close on Monday, November the 16th, the NASDAQ was down 11% from its all-time high, which was just set about a month and a half ago. The Russell 2000 has also entered correction territory. Also losing ground is the S&P 500. It is down 5% from its all-time high, also which was set in October.
[00:01:56] We'll discuss some of the reasons as to why these market drops are taking place. But since we have not had a correction in a long time, it might be a good time to talk about what a correction means. So I'll start with this. Do all indices usually go into correction territory together at some point? Anybody want to jump in? Take it. Things are really bad, sure. I mean, what an index is, it's a collection of stocks and they're driven by their prices.
[00:02:25] And it depends if market weighting or market cap weighting is the index or not. But the simple math says if for whatever reason stocks are going down, the index is correct. I guess what I'm really asking here, is this a contagious sort of thing that if one indice goes down, do they all start to go down then? Yes.
[00:02:46] When you see markets generally, they talk about in bear markets or whatever, the correlations tend to always go to one, meaning everything sort of moves in tandem with one another. So we do preach diversification here. And diversification doesn't just mean diversifying across indices, across equities, but it also means diversifying into bonds and alternatives, etc.
[00:03:07] But when it comes to the stock market, particularly the US market, in periods of trouble, correlations tend to go to one. So you have this, you know, the large cap stock market going down, as you mentioned. Well, guess what? You said the small cap indices also entered correction territory here. So things do tend to move in sync with one another at the indice level.
[00:03:32] Now, when you look under the hood, there could be certain sectors within the economy or in the stock market that don't move like that. That played out very well in the dot com bubble when the tech stock or the tech sector really, really obviously was the catalyst for the big sell off. But for actually a couple of years, the equal weighted S&P 500 was actually somewhat positive until that eventually rolled over because of the economic forces that were at play there.
[00:04:00] So certain sectors can do well, primarily defensive sectors, in periods where you have market stress across, you know, the broader landscape. So what we've seen here recently, as we've talked about for the last two or three or maybe even four months, is that the A.I. stocks and tech stocks have been declining in their value, which had brought some of the indices down a little bit.
[00:04:20] But I guess the question I have now is how much influence or have like stocks like Nvidia, which has been taking it on the chin recently, how much do they permeate the rest of the indices and even ETFs? A tremendous amount. And I'll let the other panelists speak, speak. But, you know, we've talked about this a lot where the top 10 companies are 40 percent of the index.
[00:04:47] A.I. now encompasses more than 50 percent of the overall S&P 500 in one way, shape or form or another. So it permeates a lot. But again, there are sectors that are doing well over that time frame with the with with tech down almost 20 percent. Consumer staple stocks are positive. Health care positive. So there are areas and pockets of the market that are doing well, but don't you can't get around it. The A.I. trade, the tech trade has become an inordinately large portion of the overall market.
[00:05:18] The reason why it became the biggest part of all these indices is money was flowing into it. And and now money is not necessarily flowing out of. Well, I guess it is flowing out of it. But we're going to see here in a couple of days how much how sticky this A.I. trade is. Let's put it that way. But for now, it looks like there's a lot of doubt surrounding all that money that sloshed into A.I.
[00:05:46] And it's now sloshing out. Yeah, that's so true. A lot of what I think people are realizing and we've talked about over and over again on the show is where does where the rubber meets the road. Are they going to be able to deliver earnings? And what are the challenges that we're facing going into 2027? One is that we know that corporate debt has been the driver of a lot of growth.
[00:06:14] There's not as much availability for these companies to continue to take on that level of debt. And the other thing is just the year over year comps. Like that's really what matters when we're looking at at valuations and what's going to drive the market. To answer your question, do all indices go down at the same time? I think once you start to get into correction territory, which is kind of what we're seeing particularly with the Nasdaq right now,
[00:06:44] there is a strong likelihood that that bleeds over into the other indices. Technically speaking, there are reasons for that. One is that people do borrow money to buy stocks. And as you know, markets go down and go down more significantly, there might be some forced selling in order to to cover short positions or margin calls or things of that nature.
[00:07:12] So it is unusual that we would see a correction or a bear market without it bleeding through to most indices. Michael's point about the equal weight index versus the regular index. The market weight index is important and sectors are important. And and so we want to make sure that we look at that that because there can be a vast difference between how different sectors perform.
[00:07:41] Yeah, to put this into perspective, everyone has said what I had to say except this part. This sort of activity in the market, if it continues and it's it's a bit chaotic and the and the if it continues, it will create an opportunity to enter the markets. And that's because from best I can tell at this point in time, none of this activity has anything to do with earnings.
[00:08:09] The earnings are good and we'll see at the end of the day today how well NVIDIA does did in the last quarter. And the debate there, of course, is how is it going to go forward without one man? I retired three years ago and I thought I was indispensable. And about two years and 11 months ago, I found out I wasn't. Well, that is one of the questions I was going to ask. And Frank just brought that up and brought it up. And that is, is it time to go shopping, as you'd like to call it, Kim?
[00:08:38] Well, I think every day it's time to go shopping because there's mispriced stocks that, well, in my opinion, they're mispriced for in the short term because the people who are buying or more likely selling them are saying, I don't want this anymore in my portfolio because it doesn't meet my thesis.
[00:08:57] Now, you have to remember everybody's in the stock market, but pretty much everybody has a unique idea on what makes a good stock, how long they're going to hold it and what price they're willing to pay for it. So that kind of, I don't know, stirring up like a pot that's very confused. You can always look around for something to buy. But I guess what you're really asking are our AI stocks on sale? And that's unclear.
[00:09:27] I think that we had unrealistic expectations for the last couple of years of how fast and AI would spin up and take over jobs. And then secondly, how much data centers could be built to support this. And not only that, like all of the stuff that goes into it, you know, how quickly could chips be made and how all of it, the whole ecosystem, how fast could it ramp up?
[00:09:55] And then finally, you know, what is the demand for AI? And we still don't know. So these are all, but we looked past that, right? In the last two years, we're like a lot of people didn't know what AI was, but they knew they wanted it in their portfolio. So now we have this unwind where we have to figure out long and hard what it is and how long it's going to take. How is it worth it? All of these questions are spiraling around.
[00:10:23] There are some good deals out there, but they have to match your personal style of investing. So I would, you know, I would add on to that, that, you know, the kind of when I hear that question is a time to go shopping. I think of like we've had a market correction and now there's going to be a lot of things on sale. To Kim's point, every day is a shopping day. You just have to look.
[00:10:51] And I don't think that we've hit that inflection point where I would be scrambling because valuations have dropped so much that there's all kinds of opportunity out there. This is long overdue.
[00:11:06] And I think that there are still a lot of questions about the impact that the impact that this run up will have, has had the issues that I mentioned previously about challenges next year. There's still a feeling that inflation is, you know, kind of an issue. Um, we had a retail sales number out today that was did not meet expectations.
[00:11:33] So I don't, you know, there's for us, we have a little bit more of a feeling that this volatility that we have, um, is, is justified and to continue to monitor it. Now that we're heading into the holiday season, it kind of muddies the water because, you know, people aren't quite present as much as they normally are.
[00:11:59] Um, so we'll just keep monitoring the data through the end of the year as we continue to formulate our thesis for, you know, what the risks and opportunities are for next year. All right. Michael, you're the chief investment officer. So how do you view this time period, especially with the AI stocks? Yeah, it's, um, I'm honestly, Kim probably could speak this better than I can.
[00:12:24] I'm not a hundred percent sure if the thesis surrounding artificial intelligence and the build out there and, and, and all that has really changed all that much over the past couple of months. We've had a huge corporate governance breach, so to speak, uh, with Nvidia. And that was one of the big catalysts that caused, uh, you know, these AI stocks to fall. I mean, there's a lot of issues surrounding Neo cloud companies and how much debt they have and whatnot.
[00:12:50] But if you still believe that the AI, you know, theme is relatively in its infancy, um, and that build out light is likely to continue. You can make the argument that, you know, Nvidia is the central piece to that. Um, the stock is, you know, it's 33% cheaper today than it was even a month ago.
[00:13:11] Now there's a ton of key man risk with like a company like Nvidia, obviously with Jensen Wong, but there was, you know, a ton of key man risk surrounding Apple too, with, with, with Steve jobs, uh, you know, a number of years ago. And, you know, if the next CEO and assuming it's not Jensen Huang, I know he's trying to stage his comeback. Um, that probably won't happen. Um, but if they can, I just, I just saw an alert from the wall street journal that said, he's, he's willing to come back as the CEO. I think he really would love to.
[00:13:37] Um, um, but you know, to, to Kerry's point, there are a lot of issues along, along, along the ways, right? I mean, this, this build out with AI is, is now becoming very reliant on the debt and equity markets. Um, the fed is going to raise rates one time in December, most likely another time in, in January.
[00:13:58] Um, and so we're getting to a point now where it is going to be a little bit more expensive to continue to build out the regulatory concerns with the, you know, the, the blue wave, I think is probably a little bit overdone. Uh, there are plenty of States out there that want to continue to add data centers. There's plenty of States out there that will continue to build onto the existing data centers out there.
[00:14:19] Um, but I, I still think we're in the infancy infancy here with this AI rollout and build, but in any sort of environment like that, you always go through booms and bust ups and downs in the market. And I think that's kind of what we're seeing here today. And it's the carries point. There's nothing wrong with a wait and see. You're never going to pick the bottom. There's no point in doing that. I mean, there's always a decent time to, you know, NVIDIA reports earnings with today, tomorrow or some sometime this week.
[00:14:50] There's no, there's no real need to jump in ahead of it. If, if, if at that point you're just gambling instead of investing. So quick, very quickly on the, on the data build out center data center build out, uh, during the election, all we heard was how this candidate is opposed to it. And this candidate is opposed to it. And of course, last night I saw two different commercials on for the, why we need to build data centers. So it's, it's just, you know, one of those. All right. I'll wrap this up about the correction with, with two very quick, uh, quick questions.
[00:15:19] And that is, are these corrections normally quick? And the second part of it is, do they often lead to a bear market? They rarely lead to a bear market. All right. But they occasionally do. Bear markets will be created by all sorts of things. Most of them are a, a, uh, a weakening at least of the economy, which we are not seeing. And, uh, a weakening in corporate earnings, which we are not seeing.
[00:15:49] And, uh, the, the, uh, so, uh, a weakening in employment, which we are not seeing. And we are not likely to see there's not enough people to do the work. So the odds of unemployment becoming a problem on the near term, at least is pretty slim. And, uh, you know, all those things, uh, that those ingredients aren't there. So I don't see a meaningful economic slowdown. I mean, we might have a blip or something, but nothing material.
[00:16:17] I don't think so in this time, I think correction is just, uh, taking a breath, shaking out the people who probably shouldn't have been there to begin with, uh, getting a strong hands in as we used to say back in the old days. And, uh, and, and then move on from there wherever earnings take us. I have to say that yesterday's winners aren't going to be tomorrow's winners necessarily.
[00:16:42] And I think that happens a lot in these, um, when you're looking at an index, yes, the leaders have fallen somewhat, but there is a shakeup going on. And I mean, I think that just because whatever was a, and it doesn't even have to be an AI darling. It could be any of the corrections that somebody was a leader and they fall and they never really recover. And I think you really have to do homework before you buy.
[00:17:12] And, um, I'm talking to you that, that individual stock owner, you need to do your homework. I think it's really interesting. Um, when we look at the question about corrections and bear markets, and I do think that they are pretty isolated. I mean, all bear markets start as a correction, uh, but not all corrections extend to bear markets. So you really have to look at what the dynamics are surrounding bear markets.
[00:17:42] And, uh, given what's fueling this group, the growth that we have with AI, it's revolutionary. It is, you know, going to change how we do everything basically. And when you go back in history and you look at this type of technology being introduced and the impact that it has, you know, we know what happened with the dot coms.
[00:18:09] Um, we can go all the back, all the way back to the railroads in the late 1800s. And there's a lot of correlation. Usually the markets get ahead of itself and usually. We do see some extended time of a decline in bear market. And it's really dependent upon like when you look at, you know, it's how much you go up, you know, the higher you are, the steeper it is to fall.
[00:18:37] So we want to be mindful of that. I mean, I think I said last time on the program, I would like to see this just kind of reprice itself gradually. Um, that generally doesn't happen. Um, it's something may be the catalyst to that. Uh, it could be leverage, you know, it could be that a correction, you know, causes the leverage bubble to burst.
[00:19:05] So we just want to be mindful of it. I mean, it's, um, not a guarantee that we go into a bear market. But if we do compare history to similar time frames. It's happened. So we want to kind of study those correlations. All right. I'd like to move on here. Uh, there's an elephant in the room that, uh, we haven't really talked about yet. Uh, Michael did bring it up. And that is, of course, is the CEO of Nvidia.
[00:19:31] I'm going to just open this up for anybody's comments if you want to make any or not. Uh, so what do you think about Wong and Nvidia and where things go at this point? Well, my first reaction is you can't make this stuff up. Um, it's just like, it's fascinating.
[00:19:53] Um, so what this really speaks to for us and how we're looking at a situation like this with our clients is that it speaks to why diversification is necessary. Right. Because you don't know. No one predicted this as far as I know anyway.
[00:20:16] Um, and if he is not reinstated as CEO, like he was the founder of this organization. He was the, you know, the innovator behind this organization. And I know that people want to do the comparison with Apple, but it's a little bit different because there was a time. There was a timeline for transition at Apple where, you know, this is a little bit different.
[00:20:44] And so you don't really know how it's going to play out. So the lesson that we learned from this is, you know, over concentration in any particular, really individual stock. Um, you never know what's going to happen. As, as Kim likes to say, bad things happen to good companies. This falls in that category.
[00:21:10] And, uh, I like to believe that, I mean, he has 60 people. He had 60 people reporting to him. Uh, that's a lot of people. And, uh, I would suspect that a couple of them are capable of doing his job. If given the opportunity, the question is, will the board give him the opportunity? I guess that, that really boils down to that. Or is there someone out there or some white knight out there that'll come riding in on a source and fix it?
[00:21:38] I guess where I'm going, you raise a good point here. Is the company the CEO or is it the product that they have? You would hope that it's the product that they have. And I'm just going to say something kind of snarky here, but it seems like he was, his attention was other places than the company. And yet the company was able to perform. It was able to come out with new products.
[00:22:01] You know, it doesn't look like his extracurricular activities were necessarily very recent. So, you know, if you look back, it's probably going to be okay. Now I'm going to say something kind of crazy because I think I like to. Um, there was this whole hubbub about two years ago about Sam Altman being the CEO of OpenAI and he got tossed out one weekend and there was this, all this turmoil and we're
[00:22:31] not going to go into it, but he's back baby. And somehow, you know, he did some sketchy things, not necessarily in extracurricular activities, but it was even worse than that. Like side bets on, um, he was using his own money. I don't want to say improperly cause he, but there, there were some questions about his investments. Um, you know, that were affecting the company. Anyhow, he's back.
[00:23:00] So I don't know that I can't count Jensen Huang out at this point because, um, Silicon Valley is just that crazy. Right? So I don't know, anything can happen. And he owns a lot of stock. True. He does. He actually owns, it's like 4%, isn't it? Which is, isn't it something smaller than I was smaller than I had thought at the time. Um, but still, I mean, it's still, it's in the billions, you know, it's still in the billions.
[00:23:30] 4% shareholder. Yeah. It's still in the billions. Yeah. Well, wait, he may be a 2% shareholder before this is over. Yeah. Yeah. When you get divorced, half of it goes to half of it goes away. The, um, the, the, the interesting thing there is, is you're right. I mean, he started that company 33 years ago. He's, he is the company there and from, uh, everything he does on the political side of things with, with heads of government is super important, I think for that company. And that's going to be hard to fill that vacuum.
[00:23:59] But I think one of the issues is you can see with, with a company like that is the, all the policies have been sort of in place over the last 33 years and they, they grew and grew and grew. And then they hit a meteoric rise over the past five, six years or so. And their policies, their corporate governance never really adjusted with that, with that huge shift up in, in market valuation. A lot of the board members have been there for a couple of decades now.
[00:24:26] And so you're seeing a huge corporate governance issue because they just didn't really adjust with how they are company adjusted in the world as well. And so I think that's a huge issue. And, and anytime, I mean, Carrie brought up a good point. I mean, they're undeniably, there's a key man risk with Apple, with Steve jobs, but to her point, there was a plan in place. There was a key man risk with Jensen Huang and there was never ever a, a succession plan should something, should something happen.
[00:24:55] And I think that was, you know, one of, if not the biggest reason you saw, you've seen the majority of the 30% decline over the past month. So the one quality that evidently he really had was time management because to have 60 people reporting to you and have time for these extra career activities. I mean, that's time management at its finest.
[00:25:17] But seriously, I think that one of the key takeaways from the Nvidia situation is that leadership matters and your leadership team matters. And if I'm a board member, I'm going to be asking how one person can have 60 direct reports. So I think that one thing this may cause is more scrutiny when it comes to, you know, corporate
[00:25:46] governance in terms of the internal structure of the leadership team. And also to Michael's point, the succession planning, because anyone can get hit by a bus any day of the week. So I do think that, that people are going to really step back and, and especially corporate boards to say, do we have this situation locked up?
[00:26:13] In the, in the case of the Nvidia board though, as Michael pointed out, there are several board members who have been there 30 plus years and some in the, in the teens who are there. When you're talking about governance and how the company is doing, they are all billionaires now because of the amount of stock that they're given to be on the board. And so I'm, I'm not accusing them or anything or any other company, but it has to taint how
[00:26:38] you take a look at how the governance is going, because if the company is doing well and you're doing well, then, you know, but anyway. Excellent point. And that's where everything has to start is at the board. You have to, in every board that you are on either, you know, for a public company like this, or maybe especially for a nonprofit, you have to look to see, is the board doing its job or the right people with the right skills there?
[00:27:07] And, you know, how about cycling people on and off? And you're right that, but it all has to start with the board. Just does. All right. We're almost out of time, but I do have to bring this up. And I think that there was one other element that's in the room today. And that of course is that Anthropics IPO launches this week. Kim, I love your reaction. So does one just sit back and wait or do you go in? What, how do you guys view this IPO?
[00:27:36] Well, I suspect no one can, it's over subscribed. So if you have, if you've subscribed, if you had the opportunity to subscribe for this stock, you're going to get something less than what you asked for materially less from the sounds of it. But these things can change. They have changed. And, but I doubt in this case, it will. Well, so the next question is how high will it open after it comes out at 75 or 80 or whatever that number is.
[00:28:02] And, uh, uh, I would suspect the way to approach this thing is if you look at what SpaceX did, you might look at this because they're both in the same, I think the same stage of development early on, a lot of potential, a lot of imagination as to what can happen. Some of it will actually happen. And, uh, so first everybody will want to buy it because of all that imagination and wonderful.
[00:28:30] And then they'll sit back and say, yeah, but this is still five or 10 or whoever knows years away. And, uh, maybe, and then somebody will start selling it and the stock will start bouncing all over the place. And at that point you probably ought to get maybe interested in it because they definitely have a good tool that is necessary for all this AI stuff to actually have value. I mean, this is the next stage of the AI explosion.
[00:28:57] You know, this is, they're going to do this, but this is what this learn. What's it called? Uh, learning language. I can't even say the words, the learning models that these things are. This is one of them. And supposedly one of the better ones today. My recommendation is pace yourself. You know, it's going to pop up. It's going to be this big thing. You're going to say, oh, if only I could have gotten it at the IPO price.
[00:29:22] But, you know, um, there's a lot of track record between now and the making of a real company. As Frank points out, there's a lot of potential and there's also a lot of other places in the market to make money. So there you go. I mean, they're not the only company that does what they do.
[00:29:40] So, you know, the, the moat that we look at surrounding competition and everything else, you know, right now it's the latest and greatest, but it's not, it's not unique in terms of another company's ability to create a model that's even more robust. Go back and look at when Palm Pilot, um, IPO, back in the late 1990s.
[00:30:08] And that was like the biggest craze ever. And guess what? It's not around anymore. So. The only thing I'd say is this is not investment advice, but history is not on the side of people who buy on day one of a large IPO. If you look at the average path of the top 10 largest IPOs over the past 20, 25 years or so, um, over the next 12 months, you're 30% or so poor on average.
[00:30:35] Had you bought at the IPO space X so far is an outlier, which is great. Um, but history is not on your side is all I'll say regarding that. How long will it take before anthropic stock is included in the S and P 500 or any of the other indices, uh, NASDAQs, for example? No way to predict that they have rules, but they've been known to break them. Yeah. Go ahead, Michael. I actually forget all those rules.
[00:31:02] One like with, with S and P you need something like four consecutive quarters of positive earnings or positive earnings growth or something like that. So it could be a year or so, but there are the Frank's point, there are metrics around something like the S and P that has, um, you know, corporate or company guidance and company earnings, you know, guidance in, in them. Yeah.
[00:31:27] The reason I bring that up is that, you know, we've led most of this discussion today about, uh, uh, corrections. And I didn't know if, if, if, if anthropic, it would be thrown into the mix right away and that could turn things around as far as the indices go, you know, but. Oh no, no, no. I don't think it gets to start trading in a couple of days. I understand. Yeah. Assuming it all goes as planned.
[00:31:51] And, uh, uh, but it certainly won't be in an index in any, any predictable time that's soon. Okay. Good. Good. I think they let a couple of things in that didn't meet those rules recently, Mike, because they're just so big. They had to let them in. And this may fall in that category if it holds its value. Yeah. If it does. All right. Well, we're out of time here.
[00:32:16] There is so much more to talk about, uh, inflation and, uh, interest rates, housing, sales, uh, bonds, you name it. It seems like, uh, there's a lot out there. So maybe we'll talk about some of those the next time we meet on the bull, the bear and you thank you so much for joining us. And we'll see you again in about two weeks. We'll see you again in about three weeks. . Thank you.
